The NELAC Institute
 
TNI Logo
 
 
 

Proficiency Testing

Proficiency Testing (PT) is defined as a means of evaluating a laboratory's performance under controlled conditions relative to a given set of criteria through analysis of unknown samples provided by an external source. The TNI PT program consists of:

  • A PT Expert Committee that establishes the requirement for proficiency testing.
  • A PT Board who manages the implementation of the program.
  • A PT Provider Accreditor that accredits organizations as PT Providers.
  • Private and public sector PT Providers that manufacture and provide PT samples and evaluate the results.

Fields of Proficiency Testing (FoPTs) - the matrices, analytes, concentration ranges, and acceptance limits adopted for the PT program.

Open All  Close All

The PT Expert Committee develops a standard for laboratory proficiency testing and proficiency testing samples, including: criteria for selection of the providers of the samples; protocols for the use of proficiency test samples and data in the accreditation of laboratories; and criteria for Proficiency Test Provider Accreditors (PTPAs).

The PT Board has duties and responsibilities to:

  1. Provide assistance to on the selection of proficiency testing provider accreditors (PTPA's);
  2. Evaluate new organizations seeking to become PTPA's, and monitor existing PTPA's to assure that they are following the requirements set forth by TNI.
  3. Facilitate an annual caucus on proficiency testing.
  4. Review and evaluate proficiency testing (PT) data for the purpose of determining the appropriateness of PT study formulations, concentration ranges, and acceptance limits.
  5. Provide recommendations to the National Environmental Laboratory Accreditation Program (NELAP) Board as to PT study formulations, concentration ranges, and acceptance limits.
  6. Serve as a review board for complaints between PTPA's, and serve as a review board for unresolved complaints about PT samples among environmental testing laboratories, Accreditation Bodies, PTPA's and PT Providers that the applicable PTPA cannot resolve. If the PT Board cannot resolve the complaint, then the PT Board will refer the unresolved complaint to the NELAP Board, who will make the final decision on issues raised.
  7. Represent TNI, and assume a leadership role, where appropriate, in activities involving national and international PT standards development and implementation of PT programs.

The PTPA establishes and implements a program to accredit PT Providers and to monitor accredited providers to ensure that their studies and practices meet all applicable standards. The PTPA shall meet the requirements established by TNI. An organization may apply to be recognized as a PTPA to the TNI PT Board. The PT Board will determine whether the organization meets the requirements. Currently, TNI has recognized one organization as a PTPA, the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation.

A provider of PT samples must be accredited by a Proficiency Testing Provider Accreditor (PTPA) that meets the TNI requirements. A listing of organizations that are accredited to provide PT samples for NELAP is available below.

 

PT Provider

Contact

City, State

Phone

Absolute Standards, Inc.

Stephen Arpie

Hamden, CT

800 368 1131

Environmental Resource Associates, Inc.

Curtis Wood

Arvada, CO

303 431 8454

Microcheck, Inc.

Courtney Williamson

Northfield, VT

802 485 6600

NYS DOH Environmental Laboratory Approval Program

Kenneth Jackson

Albany, NY

518 485 5570

NSI Solutions, Inc.

Mark Hammersla

Raleigh, NC

800 234 7837

Resource Technology Corporation (RTC)

Christopher Rucinski

Laramie, WY

307 742 5452

Wibby Environmental

Chuck Wibby

Golden, CO

303 940 0033

The PT program is organized by fields of proficiency testing. The following elements collectively define fields of proficiency testing:

a) matrix type,

b) technology/method, and

c) analyte.

Note: Laboratories are permitted to analyze one PT sample by multiple methods for a given analyte within a technology. If a laboratory reports more than one method per technology per study, an unacceptable result for any method would be considered a failed study for that technology for that analyte.

Laboratories that seek to obtain or maintain accreditation shall perform analyses of PT samples for each field of proficiency testing. PT samples shall be obtained from designated approved PT Providers. The laboratory shall obtain PT samples from any so approved PT Provider. The results of the analyses shall be submitted to the PT Provider for scoring.

Note that all tables are available both as a Microsoft Excel (xls) and an Adobe Acrobat Portable Document Format (pdf) file.

Drinking Water Fields of Proficiency Testing (FoPT)

Chemistry and Microbiology
The table below contains a listing of the approved drinking water (potable water) fields of proficiency testing (FoPT) analytes and acceptance limits for all analytes except radiochemistry.
DW_FOPT_2009.xls
DW_FOPT_2009.pdf

Radiochemistry
The table below contains a listing of the approved drinking water (potable water) fields of proficiency testing (FoPT) analytes and acceptance limits for all radiochemistry analytes .
DW_RAD_FOPT_Eff_2007_10_01-2.xls
DW_RAD_FOPT_Eff_2007_10_01-2.pdf

Experimental Analytes

The purpose of experimental analytes is to gather data in order to develop acceptance criteria so these analytes can be added when these acceptance limit tables are revised in the future. Laboratories accredited or seeking accreditation in the corresponding Fields of Accreditation must participate in proficiency testing study rounds at the required frequency for the Experimental Fields of Proficiency Testing. However, accreditation status will not be based on whether the laboratory received an acceptable or not-acceptable result for the Proficiency Test Sample. Laboratory participation data will be used to determine if these Fields of Proficiency Testing should be moved to the Accreditation Table in the future.
DW_EXP_FOPT_2007_01.xls
DW_EXP_FOPT_2007_01.pdf

Non-Potable Water (NPW) Fields of Proficiency Testing (FoPT)

Chemistry and Microbiology
The attached table contains a listing of the approved wastewater or non-potable water fields of proficiency testing (FoPT) analytes and acceptance limits.
NPW_FOPT_2010_01_04.xls
NPW_FOPT_2010_01_04.pdf

Whole Effluent Toxicity

The NELAP Board has adopted, new proficiency testing (PT) limits for Whole Effluent Toxicity (WET) that are effective April 1, 2009.
NPW WETT FoPT Table 2009.xls
NPW WETT FoPT Table 2009.pdf

Experimental Analytes

The purpose of experimental analytes is to gather data in order to develop acceptance criteria so these analytes can be added when these acceptance limit tables are revised in the future. Laboratories accredited or seeking accreditation in the corresponding Fields of Accreditation must participate in proficiency testing study rounds at the required frequency for the Experimental Fields of Proficiency Testing. However, accreditation status will not be based on whether the laboratory received an acceptable or not-acceptable result for the Proficiency Test Sample. Laboratory participation data will be used to determine if these Fields of Proficiency Testing should be moved to the Accreditation Table in the future.
NPW_EXP_FOPT_2007_01.xls
NPW_EXP_FOPT_2007_01.pdf

Solid and Chemical Materials (SCM) Fields of Proficiency Testing (FoPT)

Accreditation Analytes
The attached table contains a listing of the approved Solid and Chemical Materials fields of proficiency testing (FoPT) analytes and acceptance limits.
SCM_FOPT_2007_01.xls
SCM_FOPT_2007_01.pdf

Experimental Analytes

The PT Board also adopted and is posting a list of experimental analytes for Solid and Chemical Materials. The purpose of experimental analytes is to gather data in order to develop acceptance criteria so these analytes can be added when these acceptance limit tables are revised in the future. Laboratories accredited or seeking accreditation in the corresponding Fields of Accreditation must participate in proficiency testing study rounds at the required frequency for the Experimental Fields of Proficiency Testing after July 1, 2007. However, accreditation status will not be based on whether the laboratory received an acceptable or not-acceptable result for the Proficiency Test Sample. Laboratory participation data will be used to determine if these Fields of Proficiency Testing should be moved to the Accreditation Table in the future.
SCM_EXP_FOPT_2007.xls
SCM_EXP_FOPT_2007.pdf

Note:  The language below was abstracted from Sections 2.4 and 2.5 of the 2003 NELAC Standard.

2.4  LABORATORY ENROLLMENT IN PROFICIENCY TESTING PROGRAM(S)

Required Level of Participation

To be accredited initially and to maintain accreditation, a laboratory shall participate in two single-blind, single-concentration PT studies, where available, per year for each field of proficiency testing for which it seeks or wants to maintain accreditation. Laboratories must obtain PT samples from a PTPA-approved PT Provider. Each laboratory shall participate in at least two PT studies for each field of proficiency testing per year unless a different frequency for a given program is defined in the appendices.

Requesting Accreditation

At the time each laboratory applies for accreditation, it shall notify the Accreditation Body which field(s) of testing it chooses to become accredited for and shall participate in the appropriate PT studies. For all fields of proficiency testing, including those for which PT samples are not available, the laboratory shall ensure the reliability of its testing procedures by maintaining a total quality management system that meets all applicable requirements of Chapter Five of the NELAC standards.

Reporting Results

Each laboratory shall authorize the PT Provider to release all accreditation and remediation results and acceptable/not acceptable status directly to the Primary Accreditation Body, and the PTPA, in addition to the laboratory.

2.5  REQUIREMENTS FOR LABORATORY TESTING OF PT STUDY SAMPLES

The samples shall be analyzed and the results returned to the PT Provider no later than 45 calendar days from the opening of the study (i.e., first day that samples are shipped or available to laboratories. The laboratory's management and all analysts shall ensure that all PT samples are handled (i.e., managed, analyzed, and reported) in the same manner as real environmental samples utilizing the same staff, methods as used for routine analysis of that analyte, procedures, equipment, facilities, and frequency of analysis. When analyzing a PT sample, a laboratory shall employ the same calibration, laboratory quality control and acceptance criteria, sequence of analytical steps, number of replicates and other procedures as used when analyzing routine samples.

Restrictions on Exchanging Information

Laboratories shall comply with the following restrictions on the transfer of PT samples and communication of PT sample results prior to the time the results of the study (routine or supplemental studies) are released:

a) A laboratory shall not send any PT sample, or a portion of a PT sample, to another laboratory for any analysis for which it seeks accreditation, or is accredited;

b) A laboratory shall not knowingly receive any PT sample or portion of a PT sample from another laboratory for any analysis for which the sending laboratory seeks accreditation, or is accredited;

c) Laboratory management or staff shall not communicate with any individual at another laboratory
(including intracompany communication) concerning the PT sample; and

d) Laboratory management or staff shall not attempt to obtain the assigned value of any PT sample from their PT Provider.

Maintenance of Records

The laboratory shall maintain copies of all written, printed, and electronic records, including but not limited to bench sheets, instrument strip charts or printouts, data calculations, and data reports, resulting from the analysis of any PT sample for five years or for as long as is required by the applicable regulatory program, whichever is greater. These records shall include a copy of the PT study report forms used by the laboratory to record PT results. All of these laboratory records shall be made available to the assessors of the Accreditation Body during on-site audits of the laboratory.